Skip to Sidebar Skip to Content

National Association of Rocketry

  • Home
  • Join NAR
  • Site Map
  • Contact Us
  • My Membership
  • About NAR
    • Overview
    • Organization Awards
    • Organization Contacts
  • Donate

RCP 2021-015

Enter NAR login credentials for access.

Please enter your username or email address. This should be the same login you use for your NAR membership


Forgot your password? Need help?

Your Message
You have already subscribed to this comment.
Congratulation, you have successfully subscribed.

Your report has been successfully sent. We will look into it.

6 Comments on RCP 2021-015

Reply
Chandler STEVENS said : subscriber Report 7 months ago

I agree with the general premise that competitors should generally all have access to the same products, though disagree with the way this RCP enforces it. I would recommend this burden fall on the NAR competition board to hold off approving any hot new products until they've become reasonably commercially available. This is similar to how we handle new motors, immediately approved for sport flying, slight delay before allowed for competition.

Reply
DANIEL WOLF said : Report 7 months ago

 

I understand Bruce's frustration, but I think this proposal will be difficult to manage. It would also penalize those who already purchase the altimeter and were planning to use it.

There were 3 new altimeters that were contest approved in July and barely met the requirement that they be approved for 30 days so they could be used at NARAM.  Somewhat bad timing, but that's how it played out.  For the record, two of those, the Flight Sketch "Comp" and "Mini" were Contest Approved on June 23rd, making them available for contest use on July 23rd, a few days before NARAM.  The "Comp" continued to be available until September 26th, when that batch of altimeters was sold out.  So no issue with it.  It was actually available for 60+ days after contest approval, and was not sold out until September 26th.  The Mini also sold out, but since other altimeters like the Altus Metrum MicroPeak and the Perfectflite Firefly are similar and were available, they could be used instead.

The 3rd altimeter that was approved in July, on July 14th, was the NCR DeployMax.  This altimeter is unique in that it can fire an ejection charge.  It was useful for NARAM-62 for those wanting to use the AeroTech D2.3 motor in D SuperRoc since the motor has no ejection charge.  That altimeter DID sell out prior to NARAM, but I don't know if it was within 30 days of July 14th or after. I only know it was sold out as of July 24th.

The problem with this proposal is that it would have penalized those who DID purchase the DeployMax and were planning to use it at NARAM.  The 30 day period of availability was less than 2 weeks prior to NARAM starting.  Should we have penalized all of those who HAD purchased them?

As CD of NARAM, I certainly would have loaned my MaxDeploy to anyone who wanted to use it at NARAM and I'm sure others would have too. I know of one competitor who loaned his MaxDeploy to another competitor at NARAM.  Unfortunately, I  was not made aware of the issue until this RCP was submitted, and not at NARAM.   We could consider expanding the group of altimeters available for rental at NARAM (currently it only includes the Firefly) rather than take this approach.

 

Reply
Wolfram von Kiparski said : subscriber Report 7 months ago

And who is going to track the opening and closing and reopening of the window of availability?

-Wolf

 

Reply
EDWARD LACROIX said : Report 7 months ago

Though I understand Bruce's irritation, William Cook makes a very valid observation- the Sporting Code should be free of language that might penalize any manufacturer from putting skin in the game, and releasing a product that might be so wildly popular as to rapidly go out of stock regardless the timing of that product release. In particular, where electronics are involved, the innovation is coming from the true Mom and Pop operations- not from AeroTech/Apogee/Estes, who honestly have no reason to invest in developing such niche products. 

I cannot support this RCP.

Reply
CHAD RING said : editor Report 7 months ago

 

Agree with previous comment that this is an unnecessary RCP addressing a current world problem.  It also just adds more unnecessary words to an already 26,000 word rule book.  As long as the CB keeps an eye on legitimate problems (as in a manufacturer doesn't even bother to produce more units even with components being available) for like a year or something crazy, then those issues could be addressed outside a RCP.

 

Reply
WILLIAM COOKE said : subscriber Report 8 months ago

It is pretty well known that the pandemic has significantly disrupted the supply chain of small electronic parts; as a consequence, all manufacturers of rocket electronics are having difficulties obtaining components. It would seem to me that this RCP submission is trying to fix a problem that will go away with the restoration of the electronics supply chain, which will hopefully occur soon.

Also, I do not think that a manufacturer should be penalized for the popularity of their products - the altimeter mentioned in the RCP submission was quite popular due to its ease of use; the supply would have been exhausted very quickly even in non-pandemic conditions. Should NAR get into the practice of dictating how many units a manufacturer should produce? That is effectively what this RCP states - you have to have enough supply to service rocketeers - no matter how many units they buy (I bought 3 upon the initial release) - for the entire contest year. At a minimum, this discourages innovation by folks with small businesses seeking to advance our hobby and favors existing "large" manufacturers who have little to no reason to improve their product.

Finally, there was/is at least one altimeter on the market comparable to the one mentioned in the RCP, though it is much less user-friendly. So there was no loss in competitive edge - only a loss in "user convenience", which does not impact rocket performance.

The only role of NAR in the manufacturing on altimeters should be the contest certification process. 

Your comment is awaiting moderation.

Leave a Reply Cancel Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • Previous story RCP 2021-017
  • Next story RCP 2021-004
    • The American Rocketry Challenge
    • Model Rocket Info
      • The Sport Rocketry Hobby
      • Model Rocket Safety Code
      • Understanding FAA Regulations
    • High Power Rocketry
      • High Power Rocketry Certifications
      • High Power Rocket Safety Code
      • Understanding FAA Regulations
      • Filing for FAA Launch Authorization
      • High Power Resources
        • High Power Technical Reports
        • NAR HPR Certified Member Search
      • The NAR Rocket Science Achievement Award
    • Educational Resources
      • Online Mentoring Resources
      • NARTREK Skills Program
      • The NARTREK Cadet Program
      • 4-H
      • Air Force JROTC
      • Civil Air Patrol
      • Rocket Teacher Certification Program
      • Grants, Scholarships, and Recipients
      • Educator’s Newsletter Archive
    • Find a Launch
      • General Launch Information
      • Launch Calendar
      • Find a Contest
      • Register an NAR Launch
    • Local Clubs
      • NAR Club Locator
      • Find an NAR Club Launch
      • Submit a Local Club / Submit Changes
      • Section FAQ’s
      • Section Guidebook
    • Insurance Questions/Claims
    • Safety
      • Safety Codes
      • Model Rocket Safety Code
      • High Power Rocket Safety Code
      • Radio Control Rocket Glider Safety Code
    • Rocket Motor Information
      • Certified Motors
        • Motor Related Lists
      • NAR Motor Testing
        • NAR Motor Testing Notices
      • Manufacturer Notifications
      • Report a Malfunctioning Motor
    • Contest Flying – NAR Competition
      • National Scoreboard
      • US Team Selection Scoreboard
      • Find a Contest
      • Register an NAR Launch
      • Competition Results Entry
      • Team Registration
      • Teams List
      • Contest Events
      • Competition Meets
      • US National Model Rocket Performance Records – 8/2/19
      • International Competition
      • Competition Guide
      • U.S. Model Rocket Sporting Code
      • Rules Revision Process
    • Sport Rocketry Magazine
      • Magazine Submissions
      • Write It and Get Paid
      • Advertise in Sport Rocketry
      • Sample Issue
      • Contact Sport Rocketry
    • Member Resources
      • Publication Archives
        • Sport Rocketry Magazine
        • American Spacemodeling Magazine
        • The Model Rocketeer Magazine
        • Model Rocketry Magazine
        • eRocketeer Digital Editions
        • Member Guidebook Archive
      • NARTREK Skills Program
      • R&D Reports
      • Technical Bibliography
      • NAR Insurance
        • Insurance Questions
        • Proof of Insurance
        • NAR Insurance Claim Form
      • NAR Association Documents
      • Promotional Materials
    • NAR Products
    • Website Fixes
    • Recent Website Changes
    • Donate

  • Sport Rocketry Magazine

    Six 48 Page Issues a year Free with NAR Membership Today

  • Local Rocketry Clubs

    Connect with Proven Rocketry Experts FIND A CLUB TODAY

  • High Power Rocket Certification

    Design and Fly High Power Rocket Vehicles Learn More

  • Contact Nar

    National Association of Rocketry
    P.O. Box 407
    Marion, IA 52302

    Call: 319-373-8910

  • Join NAR

    The best way to get more out of the exciting hobby of rocketry is to connect with other flyers. The National Association of Rocketry can get you connected to the cutting edge of the hobby so you can learn how to fly higher, faster, and better. As an NAR member you will get:

    • Access to launch sites through local NAR clubs
    • The bimonthly color magazine "Sport Rocketry"
    • Insurance coverage for your flights
    • Certification for high power rocket flying

    Join Nar

  • Latest NAR Rocket News

    • RCP Cycle 2019-2020 23August21
    • Join a Section 03August21
    • Fly With Friends!!! 09August20
    • RCP Ballot 2019-2020 12May20
    • RCP’s of the Past 27August18
    • Sport Rocketry Magazine 27September17

© Copyright YEAR National Association of Rocketry | Privacy Notice

  • The American Rocketry Challenge
  • Model Rocket Info
    ▼
    • The Sport Rocketry Hobby
    • Model Rocket Safety Code
    • Understanding FAA Regulations
  • High Power Rocketry
    ▼
    • High Power Rocketry Certifications
    • High Power Rocket Safety Code
    • Understanding FAA Regulations
    • Filing for FAA Launch Authorization
    • High Power Resources
      ▼
      • High Power Technical Reports
      • NAR HPR Certified Member Search
    • The NAR Rocket Science Achievement Award
  • Educational Resources
    ▼
    • Online Mentoring Resources
    • NARTREK Skills Program
    • The NARTREK Cadet Program
    • 4-H
    • Air Force JROTC
    • Civil Air Patrol
    • Rocket Teacher Certification Program
    • Grants, Scholarships, and Recipients
    • Educator’s Newsletter Archive
  • Find a Launch
    ▼
    • General Launch Information
    • Launch Calendar
    • Find a Contest
    • Register an NAR Launch
  • Local Clubs
    ▼
    • NAR Club Locator
    • Find an NAR Club Launch
    • Submit a Local Club / Submit Changes
    • Section FAQ’s
    • Section Guidebook
  • Insurance Questions/Claims
  • Safety
    ▼
    • Safety Codes
    • Model Rocket Safety Code
    • High Power Rocket Safety Code
    • Radio Control Rocket Glider Safety Code
  • Rocket Motor Information
    ▼
    • Certified Motors
      ▼
      • Motor Related Lists
    • NAR Motor Testing
      ▼
      • NAR Motor Testing Notices
    • Manufacturer Notifications
    • Report a Malfunctioning Motor
  • Contest Flying – NAR Competition
    ▼
    • National Scoreboard
    • US Team Selection Scoreboard
    • Find a Contest
    • Register an NAR Launch
    • Competition Results Entry
    • Team Registration
    • Teams List
    • Contest Events
    • Competition Meets
    • US National Model Rocket Performance Records – 8/2/19
    • International Competition
    • Competition Guide
    • U.S. Model Rocket Sporting Code
    • Rules Revision Process
  • Sport Rocketry Magazine
    ▼
    • Magazine Submissions
    • Write It and Get Paid
    • Advertise in Sport Rocketry
    • Sample Issue
    • Contact Sport Rocketry
  • Member Resources
    ▼
    • Publication Archives
      ▼
      • Sport Rocketry Magazine
      • American Spacemodeling Magazine
      • The Model Rocketeer Magazine
      • Model Rocketry Magazine
      • eRocketeer Digital Editions
      • Member Guidebook Archive
    • NARTREK Skills Program
    • R&D Reports
    • Technical Bibliography
    • NAR Insurance
      ▼
      • Insurance Questions
      • Proof of Insurance
      • NAR Insurance Claim Form
    • NAR Association Documents
    • Promotional Materials
  • NAR Products
  • Website Fixes
  • Recent Website Changes
  • Donate